Navigating Feedback: How to Give and Receive Constructive Criticism

It’s that time again: quarterly reviews, annual evaluations, or even a weekly sync. For managers, these meetings can be tricky to navigate, especially when giving and receiving feedback. 

However, feedback is essential in a professional setting for the development of those you supervise. As you senior admins know, on-the-job training and skill development training for admins can be difficult to obtain. Sometimes the most powerful form of professional development for junior admins is the conversations they have with senior admins who manage them and their teams. Constructive criticism is vital to both the individual’s and the organization’s success. 

In this article, we'll dive deeper into constructive criticism, how to give it effectively, and how to receive it in a way that promotes growth.

Understanding Constructive Criticism and Effective Feedback Strategies

Understanding what it means to give and receive constructive criticism effectively is important. Constructive criticism is specific, actionable feedback aimed at improving performance. This type of feedback is crucial because it helps build trust, improve skills, and contribute to personal and team growth.

The process of giving feedback varies across all industries. As a manager, you should adjust your approach based on your industry. Here are some examples of how feedback might differ:

• Finance Industry: Feedback should be data-driven to justify suggestions. For instance, performance metrics can be used to discuss areas of improvement.

• Retail Industry: Feedback needs to be immediate and specific to enhance customer service and team morale. Quick corrections can lead to a better customer experience.

• Healthcare Industry: Feedback must be delivered with empathy and clarity to avoid misunderstandings, especially in high-stress environments where errors can have serious consequences.

How to Give Constructive Feedback: Practical Techniques and Examples

1. Use the ‘Feedback Sandwich’ Technique

Constructive feedback isn’t just about pointing out negatives; it's also about reinforcing positives and fostering growth. The "Feedback Sandwich" involves starting with positive feedback, addressing areas for improvement, and ending on another positive note to maintain morale. For example, "Your reports are always thorough. To make them even better, let's try to streamline the data presentation."

2. Offer Solutions and Support

Effective feedback is about identifying what could be improved and providing actionable suggestions and support. If you and your direct report work at a legal firm, for example, you might say, "To improve accuracy with filing, we could use a checklist. I'm happy to help you create one."

3. Practice Active Listening and Non-Verbal Cues

Providing feedback can make the recipient uneasy, so being fully attentive can ease the process. Engage fully by making eye contact and maintaining an open posture. For example, listen attentively to concerns about scheduling and confirm understanding by summarizing key points, "If I understand correctly, you're finding it challenging to manage overlapping deadlines. Let’s look at how we can adjust the schedule."

4. Be Specific and Clear When Providing Feedback

Constructive feedback aims to help someone grow and improve their performance. Avoid vague statements and focus on specific behaviors, not personality traits. For instance, if you work at a tech company, you might say, "I've noticed some errors in the coding documentation. Let's review the process to ensure accuracy," which addresses the issue without making it personal.

5. Follow Up to Reinforce Feedback

After giving feedback, follow up to see how the person is doing and to reinforce the input. You might ask, "How is the new filing system working for you? Is there anything more I can help with?" This follow-up shows ongoing support and helps ensure the action plan is effective.

Receiving Feedback Constructively: Strategies for Growth and Improvement

1. Stay Open-Minded and Receptive

Receiving feedback about your performance can be daunting and might make you feel self-conscious. However, viewing feedback as an opportunity for growth rather than a personal attack can help you develop your skills. An admin in a manufacturing company might receive feedback about process efficiency and use it to streamline operations, thereby enhancing team productivity.

2. Ask for Clarification to Understand Feedback Better

If feedback is unclear or you need clarification on how to improve, ask for specific examples to gain a better understanding. For example, "Can you provide an instance where I could have communicated more proactively?" This will help you identify specific situations where you can apply the feedback.

3. Acknowledge Feedback and Develop an Action Plan

Recognizing feedback and creating a plan to act on it is essential. Respond with, "I appreciate the feedback on my time management. I'll start implementing a weekly task review to stay on top of my responsibilities." This shows you are taking the feedback seriously and are committed to improvement.

Foster a Positive Feedback Culture: Master the Art of Constructive Criticism

Constructive criticism is a constant across all roles and industries, from entry-level positions to senior leadership. Creating a positive feedback culture within your organization is vital, as regular feedback is a part of every professional environment. As an admin, using these strategies can help foster a positive workplace culture. Effective feedback increases employee satisfaction, engagement, and retention, benefiting the broader organization.

For more tips on feedback, register for our live webinar, The Art of Giving and Receiving Feedback, to enhance your skills in delivering and receiving constructive criticism.

Register Now!